Reconstruct the following as a standard-form syllogism, and determine whether it is valid.All comets that are easily visible are taken as supernatural appearances by religious cults, and the Hale-Bopp comet was the brightest, easiest-to-see comet of a generation. So it was easy to conclude that the cults would make a big, supernatural deal out of it.

What will be an ideal response?


V = easily visible comets; H = comets identical with Hale-Bopp; C = objects that religious cults consider an appearance of the supernatural.
All V are C.
All H are V.
Therefore, all H are C.
Valid.

Philosophy & Belief

You might also like to view...

If you want to make a word's meaning more precise, a definition by synonym will work better than an analytical definition.

Answer the following statement true (T) or false (F)

Philosophy & Belief

Which chess champion did Deep Blue defeat?

a. Garry Kasparov c. Bobby Fisher b. Isaac Asimov d. Gibson Praise

Philosophy & Belief

Categorical argument forms use ______

A. only factual premises B. premises that state particular facts C. conclusions that state particular facts D. general statements for all of the premises

Philosophy & Belief

The early church fathers, when they spoke of the elements of the Lord's Table, freely used the strong metaphorical language describing it as Christ's body and blood.

a. true b. false

Philosophy & Belief