Describe whether you agree that capitalization of the tooling supplies is the preferable method of accounting for Auto Parts, Inc.

What will be an ideal response?


The client’s change in policy is appropriate. Auto Parts, Inc. likely purchases tooling supplies in large
quantities in order to take advantage of supplier discounts and in the current year they increased
their purchases in anticipation of a price increase. It appears that the items purchased can remain in
inventory for weeks or months creating a future economic benefit. The preferred accounting method
for tooling supplies is to capitalize them on-hand tooling supply in other assets and then expense
supplies as they are placed in service. The decision regarding capitalization or expense is based on
the concepts of future economic value, the matching principle, classification, and disclosure. Accrual
accounting requires expenses to be matched to the revenues they help produce in a given period.
Technically, to expense tooling costs at the time of purchase violates the matching principle.
While the “technically proper” treatment of accounting for tooling supplies was also to capitalize
in the prior and earlier years, accounting and auditing standards allow for the pervasive constraints
of cost-benefit and materiality. Prior to 2018, the amount of tooling supplies on-hand at year-end
was immaterial. As such, the costs associated with capitalizing, tracking, counting, etc. exceeded the
benefits, at least in the client’s eyes.
The cost-benefit concept can lead to interesting discussions regarding whether, in situations
like Auto Parts, it really would have been all that difficult or costly for the client to count the tooling
supplies at year-end. The problem with not accounting appropriately for tooling supplies, as in this
example, is that if and when it becomes material the client and the auditor have to exert time and
energy to determine the proper way to account for the change. In other words, not following GAAP in
this situation may ultimately been more costly than following GAAP all along.

Business

You might also like to view...

It is very common for a corporation to issue preferred shares subject to redemption at the option of the corporation.

Answer the following statement true (T) or false (F)

Business

A low-cost provider strategy can defeat a differentiation strategy when

A. sellers are not charging a price premium. B. customers are basically satisfied and don't think extra attributes are worth a higher price. C. many rivals are pursuing a similar differentiation approach. D. a company can offset thinner profit margins per unit by selling enough additional units to increase total profits. E. there are few ways to differentiate a product or a service and many buyers perceive these differences valuable.

Business

The type of auto insurance coverage that pays for the damage caused by the insured to the car of

the other driver in an accident is: A) Collision. B) Medical payments. C) No fault. D) Liability. E) Comprehensive.

Business

Refer to the following selected financial information from Shakley's Incorporated. Compute the company's profit margin for Year 2.  Year 2Year 1 Net sales $ 485,000 $ 427,550 Cost of goods sold 277,600? 251,420? Interest expense 11,000? 12,000? Net income before tax 68,550? 53,980? Net income after tax 47,350? 41,200? Total assets 319,700? 295,800? Total liabilities 174,900? 168,600? Total equity 144,800? 127,200? 

A. 14.1%. B. 17.1%. C. 12.0%. D. 9.8%. E. 32.7%.

Business