Evaluate the following analogical argument:When Halley's comet appeared a few years ago, there was an upsurge in the number of suicides across the country. The same thing happened when the Hale-Bopp comet appeared in 1997. I'll bet the next appearance of a visible comet will produce a rash of suicides.

What will be an ideal response?


We think this is a pretty good argument, but it would be improved by a larger sample.

Philosophy & Belief

You might also like to view...

"Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted" is a line from

a. the parables. b. the Beatitudes. c. Jesus's speech at the Last Supper. d. Luke's Gospel.

Philosophy & Belief

UFOlogy is __________

a. a new religious movement incorporating dance and music b. a new religious movement advocating the need to return to primitive technologiesC. a new religious movement claiming there are extraterrestrial life formsD. an ancient religious cult often associated with witches

Philosophy & Belief

The pastor of my church is convinced that the Steelers should replace their current

quarterback. So, clearly the quarterback has to go.

a. begging the question e. strawman b. appeal to ignorance f. red herring c. appeal to illegitimate authority g. no fallacy committed d. ad hominem

Philosophy & Belief

Which of the following Jewish holidays does Jesus NOT fulfill/replace in this Gospel?

a. Passover b. Hanukkah c. Pentecost d. Sabbath

Philosophy & Belief