Two engineers are having an argument about the efficiency of a tube-side multipass heat exchanger compared to a similar exchanger with a single tube-side pass. Smith claims that for a given number of tubes and rate of heat transfer, more area is required in a two-pass exchanger than in a one-pass, because the effective temperature difference is less. Jones, on the other hand, claims that because the tube-side velocity and hence coefficient is higher, less area is required in a two-pass exchanger. With the conditions given below, which engineer is correct? Which case would you recommend, or what changes in the exchanger would you recommend?

Exchanger specifications

– 200 tube passes total

– 1 in.-O.D copper tubes, 16 B.W.G.

Tube-side fluid

Water entering at 16°C, leaving at 28°C, with a rate of 225,000 kg/h.

Shell-side fluid

Mobiltherm 600, entering at 50°C, leaving at 33°C.

Shell side coefficient = 1700 W/(m2 K)

GIVEN

• Tube and shell heat exchanger - water in tubes, Mobiltherm 600 in shell

• Number of tube passes (Np) = 200

• Tubes are 1 in copper 16 B.W.G.

• Water flow rate m w= 225,000 kg/h = 62.5 kg/s

• Water temperatures

? Tw,in = 16°C

? Tw,out = 28°

• Mobiltherm temperatures

? Tm,in = 50°C

? Tm,out = 33°C

• Shell side heat transfer coefficient h o= 1700 W/(m2 K)

FIND

• Which required less transfer area: (a) single tube pass (b) Two tube passes?

ASSUMPTIONS

• Thermal resistance of copper tube wall is negligible

SKETCH



PROPERTIES AND CONSTANTS

for 1 in 16 B.W.G. tubes, the diameters are

Di = 0.870 in. = 0.0221 m

Do = 1.0 in. = 0.0254 m

for water at the average temperature of 22°C

Thermal conductivity (k) = 0.601 W/(m K)

Kinematic viscosity (?) = 0.957 × 10–6 m2/s

Prandtl number (Pr) = 6.6

Density (?) = 998 kg/m3

Specific heat (cpw) = 4180 J/(kg K)

the specific heat of Mobiltherm 600 at its average temperature of 42°C (cpm) = 1654 J/(kg K)


For case (a) number of flow passages (N) = Total passes/(passes per tube) = 200/1 = 200.

For case (b) N = 200/2 = 100.

The water velocity (V) is determined by



The Reynolds number is



The Nusselt number for turbulent flow in a tube is



The overall heat transfer coefficient, neglecting the tube wall resistance is



Case (a)



Case (b)



The Log-mean temperature difference for counterflow, is



For case (a): ?Tmean = LMTD = 19.4°C

For case (b): The LMTD must be corrected



F = 0.91



The rate of heat transfer is



Case (a)



Case (b)



COMMENTS

For these operating conditions, the double-pass heat exchanger requires about 8% less area because although the mean temperature difference for the double pass is 9% less than that for the single pass, the overall heat transfer coefficient is 18% greater.

Physics & Space Science

You might also like to view...

Suppose you live at latitude 40°N. Based on the given right ascensions and declinations, which of the following stars is never visible in your sky?

A) Spica: RA = 13hr 25m, dec = -11°09' B) Deneb: RA = 20hr 41m, dec = +45°16' C) Sirius: RA = 6hr 45m, dec = -16°42' D) Alpha Centauri: RA = 14hr 40m, dec = -60°50' E) Vega: RA = 18hr 37m, dec = +38°47'

Physics & Space Science

Pressure in a Liquid: A container has a vertical tube, whose inner radius is 20.00 mm, connected to it at its side, as shown in the figure. An unknown liquid reaches level A in the container and level B in the tube-level A being 5.0 cm higher than level B. The liquid supports a 20-cm high column of oil, between levels B and C, whose density is 900 kg/m3. The density of the unknown liquid is closest to

A. 3600 kg/m3. B. 3900 kg/m3. C. 2800 kg/m3. D. 3100 kg/m3. E. 3300 kg/m3.

Physics & Space Science

What potential difference is required across an 8.0-? resistor to cause a 2.0 A current through it?

What will be an ideal response?

Physics & Space Science

The figure shows the distance versus time graph of an object


The acceleration of the moving object is

a.
zero.

b.
constant.

c.
increasing.

d.
decreasing.

e.
not determinable.

Physics & Space Science