Please explain the prohibition of fee sharing between lawyers and paralegals/legal assistants, as well as the exceptions.

What will be an ideal response?


Both the Model Rules, in MR 5.4, and the Mode Code, in DR 3-102, prohibit lawyers from sharing legal fees with nonlawyers. That covers nonlawyer employees. The policy behind such a prohibition involves protecting the professional judgment of lawyers. Namely, if a paralegal/legal assistant were allowed to directly share in the lawyer’s fee, the paralegal/legal assistant’s work might be slanted in a way that could be detrimental to the client. The lawyer’s work, although highly compensated, must be done with professional objectivity, and the rules prohibit fee sharing between lawyers and nonlawyers to protect the lawyer’s judgment from being tainted by those whose judgment might be tainted if their performance was directly tied to fees. [This is not to say that paralegals/legal assistants would automatically lose objectivity if allowed to share in fees.] An example of illegal fee sharing would be if a plaintiff’s lawyer were to pay his or her paralegal/legal assistant a percentage of the settlements reached in cases that were brought in by the paralegal/legal assistant.
The exceptions that most directly concern paralegals/legal assistants is the allowance of including nonlawyer employees in retirement or compensation schemes. This means that paralegals may be the beneficiaries of retirement plans, such as a 401(k), or also of bonuses. But in order for such compensation schemes to be valid, the extra compensation generally needs to be paid from the net proceeds of earned legal fees, and the extra compensation needs to come from the general success of the firm, not from a specific success. For example, a bonus could be paid to a paralegal/legal assistant, but it should not be tied to a specific case

Business

You might also like to view...

Multichannel distribution

A. may involve using both direct and indirect channels simultaneously. B. may create channel conflict. C. may offer producers a way to reach customers they would not be able to reach with a single channel. D. is becoming more common. E. All these answers are correct.

Business

Developing countries are most likely to see labor standards as a way to protect U.S. jobs, rather than a good faith effort to improve the lives of working people worldwide.

Answer the following statement true (T) or false (F)

Business

The depreciable base of an asset includes the purchase price and any additional expenditures required to make the asset operational, including shipping and installation

a. True b. False Indicate whether the statement is true or false

Business

Michelin Tire Company produces a variety of tires at factories in South Carolina. Name three B2B markets in which Michelin might sell its tires.

What will be an ideal response?

Business