Identify a common critique of divine command theory.

A. It is irrelevant because the number of people with irreligious or atheistic beliefs far outnumber the number of religious people in the world.
B. It is not a valid theory because religious scriptures do not specify that God commanded everyone to live a morally just life.
C. It is problematic because there are no independent criteria to determine if someone's actions were actually commanded by God.
D. It is self-contradictory in that it identifies morality as independent of God's will and yet expects people to follow God's commands unquestioningly.


Answer: C

Philosophy & Belief

You might also like to view...

During the last century, Hinduism has become a ____________ religion

a. missionary b. global c. cross-cultural d. world

Philosophy & Belief

"The conclusion follows from the premises" means

a. the conclusion is true b. the conclusion is supported by true premises c. the conclusion is probably true d. given the premises, the conclusion follows necessarily or probably

Philosophy & Belief

INSTRUCTIONS: Select the answer that best characterizes each argument. Mary Beth complains that our curriculum is weak in areas relating to diversity. But have you seen that girl's tattoos? They're really something else-especially the red one right above her rear. And she must have a pound of metal stuck in her body. Two big loops hang from her ears, there's a small bar bell through her tongue,

and another through her navel. Let's see ... . Shall we move on to the next topic? A) Straw man. B) Complex question. C) No fallacy. D) Red herring. E) Argument against the person, abusive.

Philosophy & Belief

In a free society founded on the separation of Church and State, there ought to be no punishment for so-called "false"  beliefs

Behavior is another thing, however. If religious differences lead us to cause harm to others, then that behavior needs to be ________. (a) exempted from governmental review because of freedom of religion (b) praised because it manifests religious beliefs and values (c) suppressed because it is fundamentally hateful act of terrorism (d) examined to determine if any laws have been broken

Philosophy & Belief