The prosecutor knows that the primary eyewitness, Bill, who identified the defendant Tom as the suspect identified someone else, Harry, before picking Tom out of a line up of suspects. Does the prosecutor have to inform the defense counsel of this fact?
What if the prosecutor, in his discretion, concluded that Bill was merely nervous or made a minor error before picking out the right guy? Does the legal analysis about the prosecutor's duty to disclose the information change?
What will be an ideal response?
ANSWER: Answers may vary: Again, students are asked to determine the limits and extent of the Brady doctrine and the prosecutor's obligation to disclose exculpatory evidence. The question illuminates the ‘fox is watching the henhouse' nature of the prosecutor deciding what type of evidence is, or is not, exculpatory for the defendant.
You might also like to view...
Discuss and define “moral panic.” Provide an example and discuss why these may lead to unethical policies.
What will be an ideal response?
The Falun Gong emerged in the 1990s and since then what void have they filled for the Chinese masses?
a. Cultural b. Religious c. Political d. Socio-economic
The George County Subdivison has decided to form a neighborhood watch program to combat recent criminal activity. Luke Smith has been chosen as the chairperson for this organization. Mr. Smith felt it would be proactive to invite representatives from the local police department for their input so they can fight this problem together. At the meeting, Mr. Smith and law enforcement agree to increase bike and foot patrol to make their presence known. This would be an example of _________ policing. a. community b. watchman c. order maintenance d. functional e. service watch
What will be an ideal response?
The typical ________ of the 1940s was a walled prison with large, tiered cellblocks, a yard, shops, and industrial workshops.
Fill in the blank(s) with the appropriate word(s).