What are the limitations on the power of courts to impose community supervision conditions? Why are these limitations important?

What will be an ideal response?


By virtue of a criminal conviction, offenders have diminished constitutional rights, but they nonetheless retain rights that are considered basic and fundamental. When fundamental constitutional rights are limited or infringed upon by a condition of probation, the government must establish a "compelling state interest" that would justify keeping the condition. First Amendment rights of religion, speech, assembly, press, and petitioning the government for redress of grievances are considered basic, fundamental rights that deserve protection by the courts. For example, much of the literature of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) refers to monotheistic principles and encourages prayer, leading the court to conclude that, although not a religion per se, the elements of AA infringe on a person's First Amendment rights of religion. In other situations, the diminishment of rights is seen, as when the courts ruled that offenders could be instructed to discuss their participation in illegal activities for rehabilitative purposes or when the Supreme Court permitted the search of a probationer's home based on reasonable grounds. Giving the courts the power to impose conditions maximizes the protection of society and the ability to address and possibly treat the underlying causes of the offender's behavior. Such conditions, however, must be applied in a constitutionally sound manner that complies with the law.

Criminal Justice

You might also like to view...

________ surveys are data gathering methods that involve asking respondents to admit to various behaviors

Fill in the blank(s) with correct word

Criminal Justice

Young children are more likely to be killed by family members, whereas older juveniles are more likely to be killed by acquaintances

Indicate whether the statement is true or false

Criminal Justice

Transporting timber or wood products in violation of laws or treaties is an example of a green crime

a. True b. False Indicate whether the statement is true or false

Criminal Justice

_______________ is a method of warfare used by one side in a conflict or war when it believes that it lacks the military power of the other and so must use strategy or tactics that differ from conventional warfare

Fill in the blank(s) with correct word

Criminal Justice