Evaluate the following analogical argument:He: Let's leave Cincinnati for the golden West! Why don't we move to Los Angeles?She: Well, for one thing, we couldn't afford to buy a house there.He: Don't be such a pessimist. We bought this house here, didn't we? How much more expensive can houses in Los Angeles be?
What will be an ideal response?
Even if he is not aware of the difference in the cost of housing in the two cities, he should realize there are important relevant differences between such different parts of the country that could profoundly affect housing costs. Furthermore, if they bought their Cincinnati house quite a while ago, the changes that have since occurred in the real estate market can make a great difference in either or both localities. Note that the argument would be just as shaky if the inference were from Los Angeles to Cincinnati. (The fact that housing costs are currently higher in Los Angeles than in Cincinnati is irrelevant to the strength of the argument, though it proves that the implied conclusion is false.)
You might also like to view...
"Savings up to 70% storewide!" This ad employs ________.
A. puffery B. emotive language C. weasel words D. None of the answers are correct
Pathe is the plural of path and means “proper way.”
Indicate whether the statement is true or false.
In the context of morality and religion, which of the following best defines spirituality?
A. an intrinsic awareness of what is morally good or bad that is not dependent on one's religious beliefs or views on society B. an institutionalized set of beliefs about a transcendent god-figure that created the world C. an admirable character trait or disposition to habitually act in a manner that benefits others over oneself D. an inner attitude of reverence or deep respect for the ultimate moral worth or sacredness of oneself and others
Identify each speaker that gives an argument for his or her position in the following passage.Larry: Before we go to Hawaii, let's go to a tanning salon and get a tan. Then we won't look like we just got off the plane, plus we won't get sunburned while we're over there.Laurie: I don't know . . . I read that those places can be dangerous. And did you ever check out how much they cost? Let's let it go.
What will be an ideal response?