Describe the benefits and pitfalls of using supervisors, peers, subordinates, and customers as evaluators in performance appraisals.

Question

What will be an ideal response?

Answer 1

It is logical to choose supervisors as evaluators when they have ongoing contact with the subordinate and know the subordinate’s job. When the supervisor may not spend lots of time with the individual employee, peers may make better evaluators because they may know the job of the individual employee better than the supervisor does and may be more directly affected by the employee’s actions. Subordinate evaluations can give us good insight into the managers who control employees in our organization. We may want to use customers as evaluators when the individual being evaluated has frequent contact with those customers, because we need to know how customers feel about their interactions with our employees. Self-evaluation is valuable in a number of management processes, from training and development to counseling and disciplinary measures, among others.