A hospital-based nurse researcher at Hospital A conducts experimental research on a rotating bed and its effect on prevention of pressure ulcers in hip fracture patients over 80 years of age with cognitive functional impairment
Because there are so few patients over 80 with fractured hips and cognitive functional impairment, and because the researcher anticipates problems with obtaining consent, a convenience sample is utilized and every patient who meets the criteria and consents is used in the study. The bed, although expensive, is found to be much more effective in preventing pressure ulcers in this population than is turning alone. The study is published. What are the implications of applying these findings, considering the researcher's use of a convenience sample? (Select all that apply.)
a. The findings can be applied to similar patients who come to Hospital A, with the understanding that data collection will continue and represent a second study, since the research is unreplicated.
b. The findings may be applicable to similar patients who come to Hospital B, but without replication, this use cannot be mandated in the research report.
c. The rotating bed should not be used outside of Hospital A at all until a replication study is conducted.
d. The study findings probably represent a type I error. It is doubtful that use of a rotating bed could produce significant findings with a convenience sample.
e. The widespread use of the rotating bed has not been supported.
f. Generalization is appropriate only extremely cautiously and in the same site in which the study was conducted, with tracking of subsequent data.
ANS: A, B, E, F
In convenience sampling, any patients who meet the inclusion criteria are recruited for the study. Convenience sampling is considered a weak approach to sampling because it provides little opportunity to control for biases. Multiple biases may exist in convenience sampling; these biases range from minimal to serious. Additional studies with large convenience samples that have similar results would indicate the effectiveness of this intervention for practice. Studies with small convenience samples should be replicated to determine the accuracy of the findings and to increase the representation of the population studied. If findings are consistent over replications, then generalization to a larger group is possible.
You might also like to view...
When checking laboratory values, the nurse notes the client's platelet count is 100,000 mm3. The nurse should include which action in the client's plan of care?
1. Use strict sterile technique with wound care in order to prevent infection. 2. Instruct the client to increase her intake of vitamin C to assist in blood coagulation. 3. Hold pressure over the injection sites to ensure that clotting has occurred. 4. Encourage the client to increase ambulation to prevent a deep venous thrombosis.
Which level of prevention as defined by Leavell and Clark most closely reflects health promotion?
1. Primary 2. Secondary 3. Tertiary 4. None of the levels is related to health promotion
A client is taking finasteride (Proscar). Why does the nurse anticipate that this medication is being prescribed for male-pattern baldness and not benign prostatic hypertrophy (BPH)?
1. Taking a smaller dose 2. Using a topical preparation of the drug 3. Taking a larger dose 4. Using it on an as-needed basis
The elderly patient is taking phenobarbital (Luminal) for seizure control. What is most important for the nurse to assess in the patient?
1. Fluid intake 2. Electrolyte balance 3. Respiratory function 4. Nutritional status