Bubbly Bottling Company is engaged in the soft-drink bottling and distribution industry in the states of New York and New Jersey. The firm currently has about 40 percent of the market for these products and related services. Carbonate Distribution Corporation competes with Bubbly in the same states. Carbonate has about 35 percent of the market. If Bubbly were to acquire the stock and assets of Carbonate, would Bubbly be in violation of any of the antitrust laws? If so, which one? Discuss fully.
What will be an ideal response?
Section 7 of the Clayton Act prohibits the type of action by Bubbly suggested in this question¾a horizontal merger that would increase market concentration. Other factors include the overall concentration of the relevant market, that market's history of tending toward concentration, and whether the merger is apparently designed to establish market power or restrict competition. Based on the facts stated in the question, most of these factors are present. Thus, the major antitrust law being violated is Section 7 of the Clayton Act. Section 7 prohibits any person or business organization from acquiring the stock or assets in another business where the result would be a significantly increased market share and the effect would most likely be to substantially lessen competition. The removal of a competitor who controls 35 percent of the market (Carbonate) combined with the 40 percent held by the acquiring company (Bubbly) definitely could drive out the remaining small competitors and be a barrier to future entrants into this market. Either the U.S. Department of Justice or the Federal Trade Commission could file for divestiture of the resulting firm if these parties were to merge.
You might also like to view...
For disaster recovery purposes, what criteria are used to identify an application or data as critical?
The union of events A and B is the event containing all the sample points belonging to
A. B or A. B. A or B. C. A or B or both. D. A or B, but not both.
When you ask yourself “What am I willing to lose? What am I truly willing to give up in terms of money, reputation, time, and opportunity cost?” you are practicing which component of The Practice of Entrepreneurship?
a. Identifying your desired impact on the world b. Starting with the means at hand c. Describing the idea today d. Calculating affordable loss
To bid on a job, Budget Construction Company relies on the oral promise of Coldwater Plumbing, Inc., to perform certain work at a certain price. Coldwater fails to perform. Budget can
A. not recover due to the principle of freedom of contract. B. not recover due to the Statute of Frauds. C. recover under the concept of unconscionability. D. recover under the doctrine of promissory estoppel.