Identify and explain the rationales behind the three justifications for the exclusionary rule. Which justification does SCOTUS use today?

What will be an ideal response?


There are three justifications behind the exclusionary rule: the constitutional right justification, the judicial integrity justification, and the deterrence justification.

The constitutional right justification stems from the ancient legal saying "There is no right without a remedy.". Thus, when a constitutional right has been violated, the Constitution must afford a remedy or the right becomes meaningless.

The judicial integrity justification maintains that the honor and honesty of the courts forbid them to participate in unconstitutional conduct. Under this rationale, if courts allow evidence seized in violation of the Constitution to be admitted, they become a partner in the lawbreaking process, thus lessening their integrity.

The deterrence justification says that throwing out good evidence because it was obtained illegally sends a strong message to law enforcement. The message would not repair past conduct. Rather it would deter future misconduct by showing law enforcement what the effect of the misconduct might be.

Today, SCOTUS uses the third justification—the deterrence justification—to support the existence of the exclusionary rule.

Criminal Justice

You might also like to view...

Civil law have been used periodically in law enforcement throughout the public sector to target problems

What will be an ideal response?

Criminal Justice

Women in terrorism

a. is on the decline b. represent 5 to 10% of all terrorists c. represent 20 to 30% of all terrorists d. represent 40 to 50% of all terrorists

Criminal Justice

The most common offense committed by undocumented offenders is rape.

Answer the following statement true (T) or false (F)

Criminal Justice

Which of the following would NOT be considered a practical suicide prevention activity for a jail?

a. Improving communication between the transporting officer, jail staff, and inmate. b. Training correctional and mental health staff to be aware of the risk of suicide. c. Asking specific suicide-related questions at inmate intake screening and assessment. d. Remodeling all jail cells to be suicide resistant.

Criminal Justice