The government wants to reduce white-collar crime. a. Suppose for the moment innocent people are never wrongly convicted of a crime
Explain why the Becker model of crime and punishment suggests that we increase the fines people pay if they are convicted instead of hiring more people to investigate white-collar crime. b. Now suppose that mistakes happen and innocent people are sometimes convicted of white-collar crime. Why in this case might we want to hire more investigators instead of raising fines? What role does equity or fairness play in this case?
a. Gary Becker argues that the expected punishment for a crime is a product of the probability of detection and the punishment if detected. It can be very expensive to increase the probability of detection by hiring additional investigators but increasing the fine is very inexpensive. Becker therefore concludes that the optimal "penal code" should have a relatively small probability of detection, but it should impose a heavy punishment against those who are detected. If innocent people are never mistakenly convicted of a crime, the Becker conclusion makes sense; if we want to deter crime we should raise the fine, not the probability of detection.
b. But now suppose innocent people are sometimes mistakenly thought to have committed a crime. If we accept the Becker model then sometimes innocent people will pay a very heavy fine but some guilty people are able to get away with their crimes. This would be inconsistent with what most people would regard as a fair or equitable justice system.
You might also like to view...
A perfectly competitive firm should continue to operate even at a loss in the short run if
A. it can cover its variable costs of production. B. its revenues are less than its fixed costs. C. it has some fixed costs that cannot be brought down to zero. D. its output is above the break-even point.
Refer to Figure 18.1. The opportunity cost of bicycles in Canada is
A) 1/2 of a hang glider. B) 2/3 of a hang glider. C) 2 hang gliders. D) 4 hang gliders.
If both the demand and supply increase, the equilibrium quantity ________ and the equilibrium price ________
A) increases; falls B) decreases; might rise, fall, or not change C) decreases; rises D) increases; might rise, fall, or not change
Explain how the following factors will shift the demand curve for Gillette shaving cream
a. The price of a competitor's shaving cream increases. b. With an increase in unemployment, the average level of income in the economy falls. c. Shaving gels and foams, marketed as being better than shaving creams, are introduced in the market.