Suppose you and I are identical. We put up fireworks in our adjacent backyards on a national holiday, and we can both enjoy each other's fireworks.
a. Can you identify an externality?
b. Can you identify any missing markets?
c. Do you think we will provide more or less than the efficient number of fireworks?
d. If we could vote on a tax to be imposed on us fund fireworks in our back yards, would we vote for a lump sum tax (imposed equally on both of us) that will cause more fireworks to be put up than what we would put up on our own?
e. Suppose instead the government implements a Pigouvian subsidy. How would the number of fireworks compare to what would happen in (d)? How much of a subsidy would you think we would both get for every dollar of fireworks each of us individually buys?
What will be an ideal response?
a. The externality arises from the fact that I produce benefits for you and you produce benefits for me -- but neither you nor I are considering the benefits we impose on the other when we choose our fireworks level.
b. The missing markets are the markets for the goods we are producing for the other. I produce fireworks for you, and you produce fireworks for me -- but there is no market to price these.
c. We will produce an inefficiently small number of fireworks because of the positive externality.
d. We would both be better off if the efficient quantity were produced -- and thus, if we could commit to both be taxed, would vote for an efficient level of that tax to fund an efficient level of fireworks.
e. The efficient Pigouvian subsidy would implement the efficient level of fireworks -- just as in (d). Since we are identical, the subsidy would match our spending dollar for dollar.
You might also like to view...
Total surplus is at its minimum when the market operates at the equilibrium price and quantity
a. True b. False Indicate whether the statement is true or false
Which of the following is the best example of the substitution effect?
A. Joe buys fewer apples and more oranges as the result of an increase in the price of apples. B. Joe buys more apples when his income increases. C. Joe buys an apple slicer when the price of apples decreases. D. Joe buys less sugar as the result of an increase in price of apples.
Jacob buys less soda when the price of soda rises 10 percent, while the prices of all other goods also rise 10 percent. Jacob is
A. suffering from money illusion. B. worrying too much about a coming recession. C. paying too much attention to changes in relative prices. D. behaving in accordance with classical economic theory.
In competitive markets:
A) all exchanges take place involuntarily. B) there is only one seller and many buyers. C) prices play a critical role D) there is no provision for the protection of property rights.