Consider the following case. ? You and six others have been drifting in an open lifeboat for weeks. You have no food or water left, and all efforts to catch fish or seabirds for food have failed. There is no realistic hope of rescue. Everyone will die soon unless food can be provided somehow, and everyone is getting too weak and sick even to try to get food. Since you are the weakest and
sickest person in the boat, you are told that, according to the "Custom of the Sea," you will be killed and eaten so the rest may have a chance of survival. ? Now, using at least two of the four major ethical theories we have studied (Kant's duty-defined morality, Bentham's or Mill's utilitarianism, Aristotle's virtue ethics, and the feminist ethics of care), make an argument that the others in the lifeboat would be doing something morally wrong if they ate you. Use at least one of the ethical theories to argue for your position, and at least one other as a counterargument to be refuted. Alternatively, you may use at least one of the ethical theories we have studied to make an argument that eating you would be morally acceptable, even right, in the circumstances, defeating the counterarguments of another ethical theory.
What will be an ideal response?
This essay requires students to develop their arguments based on at least two of the four major competing ethical theories. Applying these ethical theories, in the situation as described, will likely lead students to divergent conclusions about the morality of the proposed cannibal act. Students may also find themselves arguing against their own moral intuitions. In former times, sailors not infrequently had to make decisions like these (see Neil Hanson's The Custom of the Sea).
You might also like to view...
According to Kant suicide was never moral because it violated
a. the rule about respecting persons b. the rule about respecting one’s self c. the reverence for life principle d. all of the above
Stare decisis is the doctrine that even though a court has pronounced a principle of law applicable to a certain set of facts, other judges should follow common sense in determining whether to apply that principle to other cases in which the facts are substantially the same.
Answer the following statement true (T) or false (F)
In a traditional Chinese funeral, which of the following is done after the burial?
a. The rituals immediately discontinue after the funeral. b. The clothes worn by the mourners are preserved. c. The family's mourning period stops after thirty days. d. The deceased are offered special prayers at home.
Young people must prepare for marriage in the same way that they prepare to drive and to swim. Learning to swim and learning to drive require practice. No one can learn to drive unless he or she gets behind the wheel, and no one can learn to swim unless he or she gets into the water. Thus, the only way men and women can prepare for marriage is to live together and practice it.
Analyze the following argument in terms of the schema for arguments from analogy. Briefly state at least one criticism that calls the strength of the argument into question.