What are the arguments against the implementation of judicial review?
What will be an ideal response?
Arguments against the principle of judicial review state that giving judges independent authority potentially sacrifices effective government on the altar of limited government. During a serious national crisis, for example, perhaps an elected government should be allowed to try something—anything—without worrying whether a Supreme Court will overturn its proposals. Others object that giving unelected and unaccountable judges the power to invalidate legislation actually violates the definition of democracy as a political system in which the rulers are accountable to the ruled. Opponents of judicial review argue that democracy requires that elected officials interpret the constitution, not unelected judges. They also suggest that it is impractical to assume that unelected judges will be politically impartial. After all, elected politicians from one political party or another typically appoint those judges in the first place—and politicians tend to nominate judges who share their political interests. Because voters neither hire nor fire judges, judicial review insulates a set of political actors from both voters and elected officials.
You might also like to view...
Criticisms of political parties date back to which of the following?
a. The Gettysburg Address b. The 1900 State of the Union speech c. Washington's Farewell Address d. The Industrial Revolution e. Theodore Roosevelt's presidency
The state has attempted to reduce the prison population through a. realignment
b. reducing some felonies to misdemeanors. c. keeping offendors in local jails. d. all of these.
Look at the research matrix below without column headings. What type of design does this research matrix represent?
High hurry High hurry Helping relevant Task relevant Intermediate hurry Intermediate hurry Helping relevant Task relevant Low hurry Low hurry Helping relevant Task relevant a. 2 X 3 b. 3 X 2 c. 2 X 2 d. cannot be determined
What was the "era of the partisan press"?
A) a period prior to the Civil War when the press was overly partial to the federal government and acted as its mouthpiece B) a period prior to the Civil War when most newspapers were owned by, or at least supported, one of the major political parties, and this bias was evident in their news C) a period prior to the Civil War when the Democratic Party controlled all news sources D) a period prior to and during World War II when the federal government issued a blackout order for all news reports about the war E) a period of government censorship during the Civil War when all news outlets were controlled by the federal government