What national security risks are presented to the United States by China and India? How likely would a multilateralist U.S

president be to rely on diplomacy instead of military action in dealing with these countries? How likely is it that diplomacy would succeed with each of these countries during a crisis situation? Provide a justification for your answer.

What will be an ideal response?


An ideal response will:
1, Discuss some aspects of the military threat posed by China with its huge population, fast-growing economy, and increased defense spending to rapidly upgrade and modernize its military.
2, Identify some of the tensions between China and the United States regarding disputes over trade, intellectual property rights protections, the valuation of Chinese currency, human rights, Chinese opposition to U.S. policies regarding various countries, the indebtedness of the United States to China for low-interest loans, and China's nuclear program.
3, Describe the primary U.S. concern with India as the threat of nuclear war between it and Pakistan.
4, Note that a multilateralist president would very likely seek diplomatic solutions first in a crisis situation, as a multilateralist believes in international cooperation and would favor negotiation over military solutions whenever possible.
5, Identify China as potentially the most difficult country to deal with diplomatically, given its lack of concessions during Obama's 2009 visit, its refusal to sign an arms reduction treaty or to back the United States in dealing with Iran and North Korea, its opposition of U.S. policies in various countries, its cyber attacks on American firms to gain access to technology, and so on.
6, Propose that India has high potential for being receptive to U.S. diplomatic efforts, as shown by the 2006 nuclear cooperation treaty signed by President George W. Bush, the stronger strategic alliance that is being formed between the United States and India in response to rising Chinese economic and military power, the increasing economic ties between the United States and India, U.S. sympathy for India as a target of terrorist attacks thought to be encouraged by Pakistan, and so on.

Political Science

You might also like to view...

By 1979, Carter's foreign policy began to be criticized. It was inconsistent and although some successes in Carter's global approach might be identified, too many problems were evident, without a clear strategy for dealing with them. Which of the following was NOT one of those problems?

a. A revolution in Nicaragua, with the United States adopting a policy that pleased neither the Somocistas nor the Sandinista b. A revolution in Iran that replaced the Shah (whom the Carter administration had supported) with a markedly anti-American regime c. The idealism and lack of foreign policy shift in Carter's last year of office d. The continuing growth of Soviet power without an American response e. The stalled Middle East peace effort, with Arab rejection of the Camp David framework

Political Science

Unlike other laws, constitutions tend to be immune to political pressures

Indicate whether the statement is true or false

Political Science

Which of the following is a reason that led to the fall of the Tokugawa regime?

A. The bakufu and daimyo grew richer while the samurai grew poorer. B. Samurai wanted to climb the social ladder to become daimyos and shoguns and were unhappy that status was hereditary. C. Traditional methods were still prevalent in commerce and lacked modernization. D. The revenue sources of the Tokugawa bakufu increased. E. The Tokugawa leaders rarely carried out land surveys, which made it hard to tax subjects fully.

Political Science

What is the “CNN effect?”

a. A term for what some believe to be the impact of liberal bias in the media on U.S. foreign policy b. A term for what some believe to be the impact of conservative bias in the media on U.S. foreign policy c. A term for the possible effects of increasing centralization in the media on U.S. foreign policy d. A term for what some believe is the effect of instantaneous transmission of photographs and text on U.S. foreign policy

Political Science