Briefly discuss the evolution of the concept of transfer of learning. Include the following concepts in your discussion: doctrine of formal discipline; theory of identical elements; positive, negative, and zero transfer; specific and general transfer; near and far transfer; and high- and low-road transfer
What will be an ideal response?
During the early part of the twentieth century, it was generally believed that the mind was like a muscle and that the ability to think, memorize, and reason was fostered by studying difficult subjects that required a great deal of discipline; hence the term doctrine of formal discipline. This doctrine incorrectly maintained that learning difficult subjects improved a student's ability to memorize, think, and reason. At the same time, Thorndike and Woodworth proposed that the degree to which knowledge or the understanding of one task facilitates learning another task depends on how similar the two tasks are. This was called the theory of identical elements.
Subsequently, other psychologists studied the phenomenon of transfer and identified different
forms. The first distinction was between positive, negative, and zero transfer. Positive transfer occurs when prior knowledge facilitates the learning of a new task. Negative transfer occurs when prior knowledge impedes the learning of a new task. Zero transfer occurs when prior knowledge has no effect on the learning of new material. Specific transfer and general transfer are types of positive transfer. Specific transfer occurs when there are specific structural similarities between the two tasks. General transfer occurs when these structural similarities do not exist but similar cognitive processes are used to meet the demands of both tasks. Near transfer and far transfer are also forms of positive transfer that are similar in
some respects to specific transfer and general transfer, respectively, but the conditions under which they occur are specified in more detail. Near transfer occurs when the knowledge domains for two tasks are highly similar, the settings for the original and transfer tasks are basically the same, and the elapsed time between the original and transfer tasks is relatively brief. Far transfer occurs when the knowledge domains and settings are dissimilar and the time between the two tasks is relatively long.
Contemporary views of transfer include the concepts of high- and low-road transfer. Low-road transfer occurs when previously learned information is automatically retrieved from memory and applied to learning a new task. Students must be given ample opportunity to practice one skill in a variety of different settings before low-road transfer will automatically occur. High- road transfer, on the other hand, refers to a conscious attempt to formulate an abstraction (rule, schema) that allows a connection between two tasks. Metaphors can be thought of as high-road transfer, since a metaphor is a blueprint of sorts, or an abstraction, which can be used to represent one or more concepts or ideas.
You might also like to view...
Explain how to plan a creative movement activity
What will be an ideal response?
Software such as Measurement in Motion and Dart Traineruse this instructor–supplied resource to allow for ease of measurement and analysis of movementperformance
A) tablets B) apps C) software D) videos
What are the similarities and differences between an ATM card and a debit card?
A. Both let you get cash at an ATM machine, but a debit card can be used to make cash or credit purchase in a store. B. Both let you get cash at an ATM machine, but a debit card withdraws the funds from your account immediately. C. Both can be used to make purchases in stores, but the ATM card requires a PIN. D. Both withdraw money from a banking account. The ATM card requires the use of a PIN. but a debit card requires a personal signature.
Assistive technology ______ refers to any item, piece of equipment, or system that is used to increase, maintain, or improve the functional capabilities of children with disabilities.
A. service B. device C. system D. product