There are two firms in the residential paint industry, Cool Shades (C) and Warm Hues (W). They collude to share the market equally. They jointly set a monopoly price and split the quantity demanded at that price. Here are their options:
i. They continue to collude (no cheating) and make $36 million each in profits.
ii. One firm cheats and the other does not. The firm that cheats makes a profit of $42 million whereas the firm that doesn't makes a profit of $27 million.
iii. They both cheat and each firm makes a profit of $21 million.
a. Construct a payoff matrix for these two firms.
b. How does this situation relate to the prisoner's dilemma?
c. If each firm acted noncooperatively, how much profit would each make?
d. Are the firms better off colluding (with no cheating) or competing? Explain.
a. The payoff matrix:
b. With a prisoner's dilemma, cooperative behavior - each prisoner standing firm without admitting to anything - leads to the best outcome for each player. But each player stands to gain by cheating. Similarly, in this case, each firm has the potential to make a profit of $27 million ($6 million above the outcome with collusion) if it unilaterally increases output. But if both acted on this incentive, then each ends up with only $21 million in profit. This outcome is inferior to cooperation.
c. Each firm has the potential to make a profit of $42 million if one cheats and the other does not. But if both cheat, then profits fall to $21 million each.
d. If they colluded (no cheating), each firm stands to make $36 million, an outcome which is superior to the cheating outcome.
You might also like to view...
The trade-offs made by the U.S. government to fund the war in Iraq
A) exceed the benefits derived from the war. B) show that the government is justified in its war spending. C) prove that the government is spending too much on the war. D) represent what was potentially sacrificed to engage in the war.
Identify three key factors that can cause a shift in the aggregate demand curve
What will be an ideal response?
When the economy enters into a recession, your employer is ________ to reduce your wages because ________
A) likely; aggregate demand is vertical in the long run B) unlikely; lower wages reduce productivity and morale C) likely; output prices always fall during recession D) unlikely; output and input prices generally fall during recession
Conventional wisdom holds that there are __________ in banking
A) economies of scope but not scale B) economies of scale but not scope C) economies of both scope and scale D) neither scope nor scale economies