If judges are supposed to make decisions on an issue based solely on the facts and applicable law, what is the role of ethical norms in influencing a judge's decision?
What will be an ideal response?
A judge's claiming or implying allegiance to a particular ethical norm focuses our attention on a specific category of desired conduct. Courts do not often announce their preferred pattern of ethical norms. Therefore, it is up to us to infer their identity from the court's reasoning. As critical thinkers, we want to use the ethical norms, once we find them, as a basis for evaluating the reasoning. Since any given fact pattern may be susceptible to more than one interpretation of more than one rule of law, the judge's emphasis of one ethical norm over another often explains why the judge chose to emphasize one particular interpretation over all others. For example, if a particular court issues decisions that consistently emphasize efficiency over personal freedom, a lawyer can better predict the direction of a future interpretation of a similar law involving a different set of facts.
You might also like to view...
Fortune Drilling Company acquires a mineral deposit at a cost of $5,900,000. It incurs additional costs of $600,000 to access the deposit, which is estimated to contain 2,000,000 tons and is expected to take 5 years to extract. Compute the depletion expense for the first year assuming 418,000 tons were mined.
A. $1,358,500. B. $1,233,100. C. $1,180,000. D. $1,280,000. E. $1,300,000.
Problems of matching supply and demand for a new product often occur when a marketing plan calls for quick expansion into many different types of channels at the same time.
Answer the following statement true (T) or false (F)
The systems design phase of the SDLC is analogous to the maintenance process of designing changes
Indicate whether the statement is true or false
Does the data provide enough evidence to conclude that, at the 1% significance level, the final mark and the mid-term test mark show a positive linear relationship?
What will be an ideal response?