A nurse manager is directing a team of staff nurses working to solve a clinical problem using evidence-based practice (EBP)

Question

Which manager statements would direct these nurses to the forms of strongest clinical evidence? Note: Credit will be given only if all correct choices and no incorrect choices are selected. Standard Text: Select all that apply. 1. "We may find studies that use only one group of subjects."
2. "Look for articles that report on how to use evidence in other clinical situations."
3. "The studies we want are built around the scientific approach to solving problems."
4. "Our focus should be on studies that use both experimental and control groups to determine intervention effectiveness."
5. "Many articles will have information reported by someone who is an expert in the field."

Answer 1

3,4
Rationale 1: Studies using only one group of subjects are done in a quasi-experimental design. This is not one of the two strongest forms of evidence.
Rationale 2: An in-depth analysis used to translate information to other clinical situations is a case study approach. This is not one of the two strongest forms of evidence.
Rationale 3: Using the scientific approach results in statistical evidence, which is one of the two strongest forms.
Rationale 4: Studies that use both experimental and control groups are randomized control trials. This is one of the two strongest forms of evidence.
Rationale 5: Evidence reported by an expert in the field is testimonial evidence. It is not one of the two strongest forms of evidence.
Global Rationale: