Manuel applied for a variance from the local zoning ordinance in order to build a building. His neighbor, Sandra, appeared before the zoning board to speak in opposition to the application. At the hearing, Sandra testified under oath and made several
untruthful statements regarding Manuel's character which she believed, but which were not correct. The variance was denied. Manuel is now considering a lawsuit against Sandra for slander. Does Manuel have a valid cause of action against Sandra? Explain. What are the elements that he must prove to win a case of slander? What defenses can Sandra raise to the action?
Slander is oral defamation, which consists of a false communication that injures a person's reputation by disgracing him and diminishing the respect in which he is held. It is an intentional tort and thus requires that the false statements be made with "intent," which is defined as "the desire to cause the consequences of an act or knowledge that the consequences are substantially certain to result from the act." In the case of a nonpublic figure, there is no requirement of "actual malice," or knowledge of the falsity or the reckless disregard for the truth. In the absence of any information indicating that Manuel is a public figure, the statements made by Sandra probably constitute defamation. Sandra could not raise the absolute defense of truth, because the statements were untrue. She also could not raise the First Amendment privilege, because Manuel is not a public figure. She might possibly raise a conditional privilege which is available to protect one's own legitimate interests or sometimes the interests of another. If she acted in an excessive manner or for an improper purpose, a conditional privilege would not be available, and Sandra would be guilty of defamation.
You might also like to view...
Because we have two samples when testing the significance of the difference between two percentages instead of the one that we worked with for a hypothesis test, the standard error term is calculated differently, called the standard error of the
difference between two percentages. Indicate whether the statement is true or false
Eva Gomez is considering investing money in the common stock of Casa Corporation. She has obtained the annual report of the company and calculated the ratios presented in your text. Eva knows that her calculations are accurate, but does not know if the
ratios indicate favorable or unfavorable things about the company. What three standards of comparison are available to Eva? What would each of the standards tell her about her ratios?
Right Motors calls its customers after they purchase an automobile from the dealership. In addition, every year customers are asked to complete a short survey about the car they purchased from Right Motors and their customer-service experiences with the dealership. Right Motors is an example of a(n) ___ system.
A. open B. closed C. open-door D. environmental E. ongoing
An accounts receivable aging schedule is used to
A) decide whether to extend credit. B) determine whether legal action should be taken against a customer with a past due account. C) provide information about whether the firm's prices are too low. D) monitor accounts receivable. E) make decisions regarding the length of time a firm should take before paying suppliers.