What was Operation Cast Lead? Explain the controversy over the invasion. What is your opinion? Explain

Question

What will be an ideal response?

Answer 1

• On December 27, 2008 Israel kicked off Operation Cast Lead, a devastating air and artillery assault on Gaza that was followed by a ground invasion on January 3.
• According to news reports, several nations condemned the Israeli incursion and the United States urged Israel to show restraint.
• Supporters of Israel were infuriated stating that Israel had a right to defend itself. They asked why had there been no international outcry against Hamas' rocket attacks.
• Critics only emerged, the supporters argued, when Israel took steps to defend its borders.
• Israel maintained the attack for 22 days, destroying munitions and supplies.
• They also targeted underground tunnels Hamas used to bring in military stores? fighting caused hundreds of casualties.
• Controversy over the invasion centered on proportionality.
• Strategic results might eventually be questionable, but the tactical results were clear.
• Faced with rocket attacks, Israel responded with overwhelming military force.
This temporarily eradicated Hamas' military capability while ensuring that Israeli troops would suffer minimal casualties during the fighting.
• This exacts a high humanitarian toll, but it reflects legitimate military action and it was a tactical success.