Merit pay is highly controversial. Describe three arguments supporting merit pay, and then provide three criticisms of merit pay

What will be an ideal response?


First, proponents argue that rewarding exemplary teaching performance makes sense and that money can provide incentives for teacher excellence. Second, advocates also claim that effective merit pay systems encourage brighter and more competent people to consider teaching as a career and will also encourage the best and brightest teachers to remain in the profession. Third, advocates further argue that evidence from student achievement data exists to support the process of awarding merit pay.
Critics make precisely the opposite arguments. First, they contend that while superficial examinations suggest that merit pay systems make sense, a closer look shows that they are ineffective. For instance, a merit system in the New York City schools was permanently discontinued because research indicated that it failed to produce gains on student achievement. Second, critics contend that merit pay is divisive, damages morale, and makes teachers less likely to cooperate with each other, and they question the assumption that teachers will work harder for more pay. Third, critics contend that research has failed to find a link between merit-pay systems and increased student learning.

Education

You might also like to view...

What do you adjust when you slow down or speed up when reading texts of varying difficulty?

a. Your study schedule b. Your reading rate c. Your time management d. Your comprehension

Education

Refer to Exhibit 12-1. A multicultural curriculum will change children's racial attitudes

a. necessarily ex post facto research b. possible to do with experimental research

Education

Generally, individuals with TBI will need services and supports in the following area(s):

a. cognition. b. speech and language. c. social and behavioral skills. d. cognition, speech and language, and social and behavioral skills.

Education

Bearing in mind that the accumulation of scientific knowledge invariably leads to the refinement or revision of existing ideas, explain how behavioral scientists may sometimes be at least partly responsible for fads in education

What will be an ideal response?

Education