Stanley Milgram followed up the original scenario in his research study (1974) by modifying variables that might have influenced the large number of people willing to comply. Describe the role of proximity in the modified scenarios. What are some implications of his findings regarding proximity for modern war technologies?

What will be an ideal response?


ANSWER:
?Among the variables that did seem to influence Milgram’s results was proximity, both between the teacher and learner and between the teacher and the experimenter. The proximity between teacher and learner ranged from complete separation, in which the two people could neither see nor hear one another, to both people being in the same room, to the two being very close, with the teacher being instructed to physically hold the learner’s hand on a shock grid. As proximity between teacher and learner increased, rates of obedience dropped to about 30%.
?
The implications of this result for modern war technologies are clear. People are more likely to press a button that harms a person if they can neither see nor hear them than they are to harm a person whose pain is apparent. The use of drones (unmanned aerial vehicles), bombs dropped from aircraft, and snipers are all examples of killing from a distance.
?
The proximity of the teacher and experimenter was also quite influential. The experimenter communicated with the teacher while in the room, by telephone, or by tape recording. Obedience dropped dramatically as interaction with the experimenter, who represented authority, became more remote.
?
The implications of this second result for modern war technologies are less clear. It appears that the relationship as well as proximity matters. The legal and personal relationship between a commanding officer and a soldier is different from that between a researcher and participants in a research study. While there are many more constraints on a soldier’s behavior, the study suggests that a soldier may be more likely to follow strong, personal ethical beliefs the more distant the person issuing the order is, and if there is no one there to observe the behavior. Issuing orders by radio may often occur in military settings, but issuing them by tape-recorded message seems less likely.

Psychology

You might also like to view...

In a splitĀ­brain research study, what will happen when a pencil is presented in the patient's visual field?

a. The patient will be able to pick out the pencil from a group of objects, but not be able to say "pencil"regardless of which visual field the pencil is presented to b. The patient will be able to say "pencil," but will not be able to pick out pencil from a group of objectsregardless of which visual field the pencil is presented to. c. The patient will be able to say "pencil" when the pencil is presented to the right visual field, but not whenpresented to the left visual field. d. The patient will be able to say "pencil" when the pencil is presented to the left visual field, but not whenpresented to the right visual field. e. The patient will be able to pick out the pencil from a group of objects, but not be able to say "pencil" whenthe pencil is presented to the right visual field.

Psychology

Treatment methods to help children who are obese to lose weight should emphasize ____

a. demanding exercise regimens b. strict caloric reduction/restriction c. avoidance of food cues d. active, less sedentary routines

Psychology

According to St. Augustine, humans can have conceptions of the past and future because:?

a. ?we are made in God's image b. ?we live in the eternal present c. ?of the remnants of sensory experiences d. ?man is the measure of all things

Psychology

Mortality is a threat to the validity of a study that is caused by _____

a. the lack of random assignment b. having only one group of subjects c. comparing subjects who are at different stages of development d. some subjects failing to complete the study

Psychology