Describe a case in which you think criminal profiling (or "criminal investigative analysis") would be successful. What type of case is it and what type of background do you think would be best for the successful profiler?

Question

What will be an ideal response?

Answer 1

Answers may vary.Profiling would be most helpful for a case in which the offender has demonstrated some form of repetitive behavior with unusual aspects, such as sadistic torture, ritualistic or bizarre behavior, evisceration, or acting out a fantasy.A successful profiler should possess several key attributes, including both an understanding of human psychology and investigative experience. There is some controversy regarding who should be considered a successful profiler. Because of the importance of investigative experience in criminal profiling, some have suggested that mental health professionals may not be fully qualified to engage in profiling. Others maintain that clinical (forensic) psychologists possess a level of expertise that contributes to the effectiveness of criminal profiling. One survey found that only 10% of the psychologists and psychiatrists surveyed reported any profiling experience, and 25% considered themselves knowledgeable about profiling. Although fewer than 25% believed that criminal profiling was scientifically reliable or valid, most felt it had some usefulness in criminal investigation. Certainly any professional who attempts to conduct profiling should be knowledgeable and experienced with offenders and the process of criminal investigation, which typically means that an individual must have experience as a criminal investigator.