Discuss and evaluate the Rawls principle of justice provided in the textbook
Under Rawls's first principle, each person is to be treated equally. It holds that each person should enjoy equally a full array of basic liberties. The second principle is more controversial. This is often interpreted to mean that public policy should raise as high as possible the social and economic well-being of society's worst-off individuals. It is criticized by both those who argue that the principle is too strong and those who think the principle is too weak. The former think that, as long as we have equal opportunity, there is no injustice when some people benefit from their own work, skill, ingenuity, or assumed risks. Therefore, such people deserve more and should not be required to produce benefits for the least advantaged. The latter group thinks that the inequalities that may result may be so great as to be clearly unjust. Therefore, the rich get richer and the poor get only a little less poor.
In developing further his second principle, Rawls imagined people gathered behind a "veil of ignorance," unaware of whether they, personally, were rich or poor, talented or incompetent. He then asked what kind of society they would create. He reasoned that the rule everyone would be able to agree on would be to maximize the well-being of the worst-off person, partially out of fear that anyone could wind up at the bottom. This view, of course, had its critics, and it represents an idealistic situation that could not likely be brought about.
Supporters of the principle of justice claim that it preserves the basic values?freedom, equality of opportunity, and a concern for the disadvantaged?that have become embedded in our moral beliefs. Critics object to various parts of the theory and would not subscribe to Rawls's principles at all. Utilitarians, for example, think the greatest good for the greatest number should reign supreme.
You might also like to view...
An invoice record usually contains all of the following elements except:
a. the customer's credit limit b. customer's identification c. items and quantities billed d. invoice date
When Joe asked Lauren to complete her self-evaluation, she only commented on the positive things she had accomplished over the past year, even though she had made some significant mistakes during the first six months. Which perception bias is she showing?
a. frame of reference b. “like me” assumption c. selectivity d. expectations
Which of the following is a way of listening that is creative, sensitive, accurate, emphatic, and nonjudgmental?
A. passive listening B. active listening C. communication apprehension D. downward communication
The ______ stage is the longest component of the interview.
Fill in the blank(s) with the appropriate word(s).