Differentiate between mala in se crimes and mala prohibita crimes.

What will be an ideal response?


Answers will vary. Criminologists often express the social function of criminal law in terms of mala in se or mala prohibita crimes. A criminal act is referred to as mala in se if it would be considered wrong even if there were no law prohibiting it. Mala in se crimes are said to go against "natural laws"-that is, against the "natural, moral, and public" principles of a society. Murder, rape, and theft are examples of mala in se crimes. These crimes are generally the same from country to country and culture to culture.In contrast, the term mala prohibita refers to acts that are considered crimes only because they have been codified as such through statute-"human-made" laws. A mala prohibita crime is considered wrong only because it has been prohibited. It is not inherently wrong, though it may reflect the moral standards of a society at a given time. Thus, the definition of a mala prohibita crime can vary from country to country and even from state to state. Bigamy, or the offense of having two legal spouses, could be considered a mala prohibita crime.Some observers question the distinction between mala in se and mala prohibita. In many instances, it is difficult to define a "pure" mala in se crime. That is, it is difficult to separate a crime from the culture that has deemed it a crime. Even murder, under certain cultural circumstances, is not considered a criminal act. In a number of poor, traditional areas of the Middle East and Asia, the law excuses "honor killings," in which men kill female family members suspected of sexual indiscretion.

Criminal Justice

You might also like to view...

Regarding the rehabilitative aim of probation, we can say that it has been:

A) and continues to be dominant in the U.S. approach to corrections. B) shifted to a lower priority. C) rejected. D) None of the above

Criminal Justice

Judges generally follow the sentencing recommendation provided in a probation officer's presentence investigation report.

Answer the following statement true (T) or false (F)

Criminal Justice

In most cities the police chief is:

A. appointed by the mayor or city council B. voted in by fellow officers C. elected by the citizens D. hired by the city manager or city CEO

Criminal Justice

A meeting is necessary when

A) there is a reason for the meeting. B) time is not limited. C) participant tasks are interdependent. D) other forms of communication are not appropriate. E) all of the above.

Criminal Justice