Evaluate the following analogical argument:Clark said gun control should not be blamed in situations when the user abuses the weapon. "A gun is an inanimate object," he said. "A plane is an inanimate object, but look at how many people are killed by them and they're not illegal." Clark said that he was raised on a ranch and has "run around with guns since I was big enough to carry them." He added that he has never shot anybody as a result of growing up around guns.

What will be an ideal response?


Clark's analogy involves inanimate objects that are too dissimilar. He then generalizes too hastily from his own experience with being raised around guns.

Philosophy & Belief

You might also like to view...

Suppose I learn from an excellent source the statistical fact that 35% of homeless people have alcohol dependence. I conclude that there is roughly a 35% probability that a randomly selected homeless person has alcohol dependence. What kind of reasoning is this?

A. representativeness heuristic B. loose generalization C. statistical generalization D. statistical instantiation

Philosophy & Belief

Living wills always include authorization for the withholding of nutrition and hydration.

a. true b. false

Philosophy & Belief

The religion of Sikhism first developed in

A. southeast India, near Madras. B. Kashmir in northern India. C. northeast India, near Calcutta and Benares. D. the Punjab region of India and Pakistan.

Philosophy & Belief

A __________ the quality of having a good character

a. vice b. virtue c. public good d. free-rider

Philosophy & Belief