What is the difference between ethical formalism and utilitarianism?

What will be an ideal response?


Ethical formalism is what is good is that which conforms to the categorical imperative. Under this system, there is the belief that there is a universal law that includes clear rights and wrongs. There is a categorical imperative that requires that each person act as he or she would like all others to act (very much like the golden rule mentioned in the foregoing). People must seek to be guided by reason in their decision-making. Ethical formalism falls under a deontological system as the focus is on the act and its rightness (or wrongness) rather than on the consequences of the act and its rightness (or wrongness). It is a position that does not account for grey areas, an act is either right or it is wrong. So some acts, such as murder, lying, and stealing are always wrong even when the end of these acts is good. Utilitarianism is defined as what is good is that which results in the greatest utility for the greatest number. So morality is determined by how many people were helped by the act. The philosopher Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832) believed that people will do a “utilitarian calculus” as regards how much pleasure or pain a given act will garner, and they will act on that to maximize pleasure. But when one’s pleasure conflicts with the greater good for society, then one must bow to the greater good, under a utilitarian perspective. As utilitarianism is focused on the end—whether it is moral or immoral or ethical or unethical—achieved by an act, it falls under the teleological system.

Criminal Justice

You might also like to view...

In the federal prison system, ______ of females have been convicted of a drug-related offense, while ______ of men in federal prison are serving time for drug-related offenses.

a. 25% and 14% b. 14% and 25% c. 56% and 47% d. 47% and 56%

Criminal Justice

Tagging is another term used for __________ monitoring

Fill in the blank(s) with correct word

Criminal Justice

Regardless of which route of administration is used, the goal is for the drug to be absorbed into the bloodstream.

Answer the following statement true (T) or false (F)

Criminal Justice

Based on lower court research, Walker concludes that lower courts are very different from the upper courts, but there are significant differences between courts in different jurisdictions

Indicate whether the statement is true or false

Criminal Justice