Joe Brown was rock climbing last month. He slipped and fell but caught his rope and managed to hold on for 10 minutes, swinging free, until other climbers were able to pull him to safety. A weekly paper, The Moon, ran an article including quotations and thoughts attributed to Brown about the incident. Twenty of the article’s 30 paragraphs included quotations and thoughts attributed to Brown, indicating Brown was scared but brave. However, The Moon had not interviewed Brown. The reporter included material attributed to Brown to make the story more dramatic. Brown sued The Moon for (a) appropriation and (b) false light. Is Brown likely to win? Why or why not?

What will be an ideal response?


Brown will not win his suit for appropriation. Appropriation is the use of a person’s name, picture, likeness, or (maybe) voice for commercial or trade purposes without permission. However, when any of these are used in the nonadvertising part of a mass medium, courts generally will not find appropriation. Here, even though the story may not have been entirely accurate, it ran in the “news” columns, and therefore likely will not be found to be appropriation. Brown may win a false light suit. In addition to publication (in the newspaper) and identification (Brown’s name was used), a false light plaintiff must show that the material is highly offensive to a reasonable person. (Argue whether it would or would not be.) Also, most courts require false light plaintiffs to prove actual malice (knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard of truth or falsity). Here, like the Cantrell v. Forest City Publishing Co. case in the Supreme Court, fabricated quotations and thoughts attributed to a person not interviewed by the paper would be proof that the paper lied—it knew that the quotes and thoughts were made up. Therefore, Brown could prove actual malice. No defense would be applicable in this case.

Communication & Mass Media

You might also like to view...

All of the following are approaches for getting an organization's news and viewpoints on local television EXCEPT

A) send a news release. B) send a media alert or advisory. C) make a phone or e-mail pitch. D) produce a video news release. E) all of the above are legitimate approaches.

Communication & Mass Media

Ethical public speakers consider the diversity of their audiences and use appropriate channels to communicate with as many of them as possible

Indicate whether the statement is true or false

Communication & Mass Media

Primary among the reasons advertisers like newspapers as an advertising medium is their local nature.

Answer the following statement true (T) or false (F)

Communication & Mass Media

Vocal variety includes which of the following elements?

A) The speaker's listening skills B) The speaker's use of denotative definitions C) The speaker's philosophy of public speaking D) The speaker's attitude E) The speaker's use of pauses

Communication & Mass Media